Quick verdict: On totals, Kylian Mbappé’s first Real Madrid season beat Cristiano Ronaldo’s: 44 goals in 59 games in 2024/25 against 33 in 35 in 2009/10, plus two trophies and the European Golden Shoe. Ronaldo scored more often per game (0.94 against 0.75). Both went on to bigger second seasons.
Few signings carried as much weight as Kylian Mbappé’s free transfer to Real Madrid in 2024. Comparisons with Cristiano Ronaldo’s arrival in 2009 were inevitable: both came in as the best forward available, and both were expected to define an era at the Bernabéu.
Here is how their first seasons actually compare, using official match records only.
First seasons side by side
| Cristiano Ronaldo (2009/10) | Kylian Mbappé (2024/25) | |
|---|---|---|
| All competitions | 33 goals in 35 games | 44 goals in 59 games |
| Goals per game | 0.94 | 0.75 |
| La Liga | 26 goals in 29 games | 31 goals in 34 games |
| Champions League | 7 goals in 6 games | 7 goals in 14 games |
| Copa del Rey | Did not play | 2 goals in 4 games |
| Other competitions | — | 4 goals in 7 games (UEFA Super Cup, Intercontinental Cup, Supercopa, Club World Cup) |
| Team trophies | None | UEFA Super Cup, FIFA Intercontinental Cup |
| Individual awards | — | Pichichi Trophy, European Golden Shoe |
Source: club season statistics from the players’ career records on Wikipedia (compiled from Soccerway and official competition data), checked 6 November 2026. Goals per game calculated by FootballPress.
Different teams, different jobs
Ronaldo joined a rebuilt squad under Manuel Pellegrini, arriving in the same summer as Kaká and Karim Benzema. He played across the front line with a lot of freedom and missed several weeks in the autumn with an ankle injury, which is why he played only 35 games. Madrid finished second in La Liga behind Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona, went out of the Champions League in the last 16 against Lyon and won nothing.
Mbappé joined the reigning European champions under Carlo Ancelotti. Vinícius Júnior already owned the left side, so Mbappé played mostly as the central striker. That made the early months harder, but his scoring rose through the season. On 11 May 2025 his hat-trick in a 4–3 Clásico defeat took him to 39 goals, breaking Iván Zamorano’s club record for goals in a debut season. He finished with 31 La Liga goals, enough for the Pichichi and the European Golden Shoe.
Who had the better first season?
Mbappé, on balance. He scored more goals, won two trophies and took the two big individual scoring awards, and he did it while adapting to a new role. Ronaldo’s case rests on rate: in fewer games he scored almost a goal a game, with seven goals in six Champions League matches.
The bigger story is what came next. Ronaldo stayed nine seasons and scored 450 goals in 438 games for Real Madrid, winning four Champions Leagues (2014, 2016, 2017 and 2018). Mbappé followed his debut with 42 goals in 44 games in 2025/26, finishing as top scorer in both La Liga and the Champions League, and had 16 goals in his first 15 games of 2026/27.
Where the comparison goes from here
Ronaldo’s Real Madrid record is complete; Mbappé’s is only two seasons old. If he keeps scoring at his 2025/26 rate, the more interesting comparison will soon be with Ronaldo’s peak seasons, when he scored 60 or more goals twice. For the rest of Ronaldo’s numbers, see our Messi vs Ronaldo season-by-season table; for Mbappé’s style, see Haaland vs Mbappé: Two Ways to Score and Real Madrid’s superstar puzzle.
Frequently asked questions
How many goals did Mbappé score in his first season at Real Madrid?
44 goals in 59 games in all competitions in 2024/25, including 31 in La Liga, which won him the Pichichi Trophy and the European Golden Shoe.
How many goals did Ronaldo score in his first season at Real Madrid?
33 goals in 35 games in 2009/10: 26 in La Liga and 7 in the Champions League.
Whose debut-season record did Mbappé break?
Iván Zamorano’s Real Madrid record for goals in a debut season. Mbappé passed it with his 39th goal on 11 May 2025 and finished with 44.
